City of Key West, FL - Meeting of Historic Architectural Review Commission on 1/27/2026 at 5:00 PM

Min 25-1671

Tue, 03 Feb 2026 13:25:05 GMT

File #: Min 25-1671
Ver.: 1
Agenda #: 1
Type: Minutes
Title: December 16, 2025
Action: Approved
Result:

25-4438

Wed, 25 Mar 2026 16:06:57 GMT

File #: 25-4438
Ver.: 1
Agenda #: 2
Type: Action Items
Title: New two-story single-family residence, new pool, pool deck, and site improvements - 309 William Street - Sandbar Design Studio Inc. (C2025-0077)
Action: Postponed
Result:

25-4439

Wed, 25 Mar 2026 16:06:57 GMT

File #: 25-4439
Ver.: 1
Agenda #: 3
Type: Action Items
Title: Demolition of existing contributing single-family residence and rear sheds - 309 William Street - Sandbar Design Studio Inc. (C2025-0077)
Action: Postponed
Result:

25-4589

Wed, 28 Jan 2026 17:34:52 GMT

File #: 25-4589
Ver.: 1
Agenda #: 4
Type: Action Items
Title: New one-story accessory structure, new pool, pool deck, and concrete driveway. Demolition of one-story non-historic shed. Demolition of pool and pool deck - 1100 Grinnell Street - Heather Korth (C2025-0080)
Action: Approved
Result:

25-4833

Wed, 11 Mar 2026 18:16:59 GMT

File #: 25-4833
Ver.: 1
Agenda #: 5
Type: Action Items
Title: Second Reading - Renovations, relocation and elevation of contributing structure. New one-story rear addition, pool, pool deck, wood pergola, and site improvements. Demolition of historic rear porch, shed roof addition, and non-historic front porch - 624 United Street - T.S. Neal Architects, Seth Neal (C2025-0100)
Action: Postponed
Result:

26-4962

Wed, 28 Jan 2026 19:24:54 GMT

File #: 26-4962
Ver.: 1
Agenda #: 6
Type: Action Items
Title: Renovations to altered contributing structure. Elevation of structure by 6”. New rear addition, rebuilding front porch, and site improvements - 304 Truman Ave - Habitat for Humanity (C2025-0101)
Action: Approved
Result: Pass

26-4963

Wed, 28 Jan 2026 16:45:11 GMT

File #: 26-4963
Ver.: 1
Agenda #: 7
Type: Action Items
Title: Demolition of remaining deteriorated real wall - 304 Truman Ave - Habitat for Humanity (C2025-0101)
Action: Approved
Result: Pass

26-4964

Wed, 28 Jan 2026 19:24:54 GMT

File #: 26-4964
Ver.: 1
Agenda #: 8
Type: Action Items
Title: New two-story single-family residence, new pool, pool deck, and site improvements. Relocation of existing contributing structure, new side and rear addition, new pool, pool deck, and site improvements - 1327 Duncan Street - Sandbar Design Studio Inc (C2025-0102)
Action: Approved
Result: Pass

26-4965

Wed, 28 Jan 2026 17:44:55 GMT

File #: 26-4965
Ver.: 1
Agenda #: 9
Type: Action Items
Title: Demolition of historic rear one-story cottage, historic side shed roof addition, rear gable addition, rear non-historic shed, and site features - 1327 Duncan Street - Sandbar Design Studio Inc (C2025-0102)
Action: Approved
Result: Pass

26-4966

Wed, 28 Jan 2026 16:54:55 GMT

File #: 26-4966
Ver.: 1
Agenda #: 10
Type: Action Items
Title: Renovations to contributing structure. Partial enclosure of rear porch and reconstruction of two-story historic side addition with new gable roof, new pool, pool deck, and site improvements - 602 Southard Street - Serge Mashtakov, PE (C2025-0105)
Action: Approved
Result: Pass

26-4967

Wed, 28 Jan 2026 17:15:03 GMT

File #: 26-4967
Ver.: 1
Agenda #: 11
Type: Action Items
Title: Partial demolition of historic two-story side addition to accommodate new gable roof - 602 Southard Street - Serge Mashtakov, PE (C2025-0105)
Action: Approved
Result: Pass

26-4968

Wed, 28 Jan 2026 17:15:03 GMT

File #: 26-4968
Ver.: 1
Agenda #: 12
Type: Action Items
Title: Renovations to contributing structure façade to install full height storefront system - 1114 Duval Street - Serge Mashtakov, PE (C2025-0107)
Action: Approved
Result: Pass

26-4969

Wed, 28 Jan 2026 17:15:03 GMT

File #: 26-4969
Ver.: 1
Agenda #: 13
Type: Action Items
Title: Demolition of bottom portion of exterior walls to accommodate storefront system - 1114 Duval Street - Serge Mashtakov, PE (C2025-0107)
Action: Approved
Result: Pass

26-4970

Wed, 28 Jan 2026 19:24:54 GMT

File #: 26-4970
Ver.: 1
Agenda #: 14
Type: Action Items
Title: Replacement of storefront windows on contributing structure with aluminum frame storefront windows - 900 Frances Street - A20 Architecture LLC (C2025-0109)
Action: Approved
Result: Pass

26-4971

Wed, 28 Jan 2026 19:36:04 GMT

File #: 26-4971
Ver.: 1
Agenda #: 15
Type: Action Items
Title: Replacement of all exterior windows and doors on contributing structure with impact rated units - 210 Elizabeth Street - A20 Architecture LLC (C2025-0110)
Action: Approved
Result: Pass

26-4972

Wed, 28 Jan 2026 18:25:35 GMT

File #: 26-4972
Ver.: 1
Agenda #: 16
Type: Action Items
Title: New wood pergola with louvered wall and pool at side of house - 812 Carsten Lane - Alex Sainato (C2025-0112)
Action: Approved
Result: Pass

26-4958

Wed, 28 Jan 2026 19:36:04 GMT

File #: 26-4958
Ver.: 1
Agenda #: 17
Type: Action Items
Title: Renovations to contributing structure. Reconfiguration of existing rear additions. Elevation of structure by 1’1” - 906 Packer Street - Bender and Associates Architects (C2025-0070)
Action: Approved
Result: Pass

26-4959

Wed, 28 Jan 2026 19:07:07 GMT

File #: 26-4959
Ver.: 1
Agenda #: 18
Type: Action Items
Title: Demolition of rear shed and partial demolition of second-story mezzanine - 906 Packer Street - Bender and Associates Architects (C2025-0070)
Action: Approved
Result: Pass

26-4960

Wed, 28 Jan 2026 19:14:56 GMT

File #: 26-4960
Ver.: 1
Agenda #: 19
Type: Action Items
Title: New dwelling unit to replace existing dwelling unit at rear - 417 Simonton Street - Bender & Associates Architects (C2025-0078)
Action: Approved
Result: Pass

26-4961

Wed, 28 Jan 2026 19:14:56 GMT

File #: 26-4961
Ver.: 1
Agenda #: 20
Type: Action Items
Title: Demolition of existing dwelling unit at rear - 417 Simonton Street - Bender & Associates Architects (C2025-0078)
Action: Approved
Result: Pass

25-4836

Wed, 11 Feb 2026 19:04:58 GMT

File #: 25-4836
Ver.: 1
Agenda #: 21
Type: Discussion Items
Title: Window replacements in the historic district
Action: Discussed
Result:

26-4973

Wed, 11 Feb 2026 19:04:58 GMT

File #: 26-4973
Ver.: 1
Agenda #: 22
Type: Discussion Items
Title: West Martello Tower (1100 Atlantic Blvd) and The Armory (600 White Street) - National Register Additional Documentation
Action: Discussed
Result: