Skip to main content
Please note: this meeting's minutes have not been finalized yet. Actions taken on legislation and their results are not available.
Meeting Name: Historic Architectural Review Commission Agenda status: Final
Meeting date/time: 3/24/2026 5:00 PM Minutes status: Draft  
Meeting location: City Hall
Published agenda: Agenda Agenda Published minutes: Not available  
Agenda packet: Not available
Meeting video: eComment: Not available  
File #Ver.Agenda #NameTypeTitleActionResultAction DetailsVideo
Min 26-1696 11 MinutesFebruary 24, 2026   Not available Not available
26-5127 12 Reports2025 End of the Year Report   Not available Not available
26-5132 13 Action ItemsSelection of Vice Chair   Not available Not available
25-4438 14 Action ItemsRequest to be Postponed Indefinitely - New two-story single-family residence, new pool, pool deck, and site improvements - 309 William Street - Sandbar Design Studio Inc. (C2025-0077)   Not available Not available
25-4439 15 Action ItemsRequest to be Postponed Indefinitely - Demolition of existing contributing single-family residence and rear sheds - 309 William Street - Sandbar Design Studio Inc. (C2025-0077)   Not available Not available
26-5060 16 Action ItemsRequest for Postponement by Applicant to April 28, 2026 - New storefront awning along Duval Street façade, extending partially along Amelia Street façade - 1114 Duval Street - Cross Key Marine Canvas (C2026-0004)   Not available Not available
26-5068 17 Action ItemsSecond Reading:Demolition of rear two-story wraparound porch, partial demolition of rear walls and rear gable roof - 518 Elizabeth Street - Bender & Associates Architects (C2026-0010)   Not available Not available
26-5201 18 Action ItemsMinor Development Plan - New one-story addition at rear of contributing structure and site improvements (The Basilica of St. Mary Star of the Sea) - 1010 Windsor Lane - T.S. Neal Architects - Seth Neal (C2025-0106)   Not available Not available
26-5202 19 Action ItemsNew 6’ wood picket gate along street frontage - 713-727 Windsor Lane - Island Fence (C2026-0011)   Not available Not available
26-5203 110 Action ItemsAfter the fact - Renovations to contributing structure. New wood deck on front façade and within the front yard of the property - 1922 Staples Avenue - Nautilus Drafting & Design Services (C2026-0012)   Not available Not available
26-5204 111 Action ItemsMinor Development Plan - New one-story structure, new 3-tennis court complex shade structure and site improvements - 1320 Truman Avenue (Bayview Park) - City of Key West/Keith Bring (C2026-0013)   Not available Not available
26-5205 112 Action ItemsMinor Development Plan - Demolition of non-contributing tennis pro shop, 3-tennis court complex shade structure and non-historic bathrooms - 1320 Truman Avenue (Bayview Park) - City of Key West/Keith Bring (C2026-0013)   Not available Not available
26-5206 113 Action ItemsNew 6’ wood picket fence enclosure along the side of the building facing Emma Street - 207 Petronia Street - Island Fence (C2026-0014)   Not available Not available
26-5207 114 Action ItemsMajor Development Plan - New affordable housing development. Total of 150 units - 241 Trumbo Road - Smith Hawks, PL (C2026-0015)   Not available Not available
26-5208 115 Action ItemsMajor Development Plan - Demolition of five non-contributing concrete block structures - 241 Trumbo Road - Smith Hawks, PL (C2026-0015)   Not available Not available
26-5209 116 Action ItemsAfter the fact - New prefabricated accessory storage shed on rear of property and site improvements - 319 Duval Street - Aundrea Wagner (C2026-0016)   Not available Not available
26-5210 117 Action ItemsNew bathroom structure for bar area - 1400 Duval Street - Bender & Associates Architects (C2026-0017)   Not available Not available
26-5211 118 Action ItemsRequest to Postpone by Staff - Amendments to the Historic Architectural Guidelines   Not available Not available