Meeting Name: Historic Architectural Review Commission Agenda status: Final-revised
Meeting date/time: 6/26/2012 5:30 PM Minutes status: Final  
Meeting location: Old City Hall
Published agenda: Agenda Agenda Published minutes: Minutes Minutes  
Meeting video: eComment: Not available  
File #Ver.Agenda #NameTypeTitleActionResultAction DetailsVideo
Min 12-313 21May 09, 2012 MinutesMinutesMay 09, 2012 MinutesPassedPass Action details Video Video
13-3955 12June 12, 2012 MinutesResolutionJune 12, 2012 MinutesPassedPass Action details Video Video
12-2909 13HARC Minimum RequirementsOrdinanceAn Ordinance of the City Commission of the City of Key West, approving an amendment to the Historic Architectural Review Commission Guidelines for minimum requirements for submittals for a Certificate of Appropriateness as referenced in Section 90-142 of the City of Key West Land Development Regulations; Providing for severability; Providing for repeal of inconsistent provisions; Providing for an effective date.PostponedPass Action details Video Video
12-2407 44a914 James Street - RemandAction ItemsSpecial Magistrate Remand for clarification of factual basis of how the guidelines were applied for the denial of Certificate of Appropriateness H12-01-345- #914 James StreetPostponedPass Action details Video Video
12-2408 44b914 James Street - DemolitionAction ItemsDemolition of house-#914 James Street-Seatech of the Florida Keys (H12-01-345)PostponedPass Action details Not available
12-2908 15513 Margaret Street-DemolitionAction ItemsDemolition of existing roof over one story structure on back of main house-#513 Margaret Street - Michael Miller (H12-01-1014)- Second readingApprovedPass Action details Video Video
12-2907 16a1114 Margaret - VarianceResolutionVariances - 1114 Margaret Street (RE# 00029920-000000) - A request for building coverage and impervious surface ratio in the HMDR zoning district per Section 122-600 (4) a. & b. of the Land Development Regulations of the Code of Ordinances of the City of Key West.ApprovedPass Action details Video Video
12-2906 16b1114 Margaret Street-DemolitionAction ItemsRemoval of front porch- #1114 Margaret Street- Richard Logan (H12-01-973)-Second ReadingApprovedPass Action details Not available
12-2905 17a610 Greene Street-DesignAction ItemsAlteration of portion of front façade for new outdoor dining patio and glass entry wall- #610 Greene Street- David Knoll (H12-01-975)Withdrawn  Action details Video Video
12-2904 17b610 Greene Street-DemolitionAction ItemsPartial demolition of façade- #610 Greene Street- David Knoll (H12-01-975)Withdrawn  Action details Not available
12-2903 18420-422 Appelrouth LaneAction ItemsRestore art deco facade of 422 Appelrouth Lane and replace involuntarily destroyed structure at 420 Appelrouth Lane-#420-422 Appelrouth Lane- Will Shepler (H12-01-996)ApprovedPass Action details Video Video
12-2902 19a517 Elizabeth Street-DesignAction ItemsRe-open front porch. New wood windows and doors. New rear addition and carport. New pool and rear deck. Repair and replace front wall and fence and new picket fence on side property lines- -#517 Elizabeth Street- Thomas E. Pope (H12-01-997)PassedPass Action details Video Video
12-2901 19b517 Elizabeth Street-DemolitionAction ItemsDemolition of rear additions, carport, garage, side deck and portion of side one story addition-#517 Elizabeth Street- Thomas E. Pope (H12-01-997)-Second readingApprovedPass Action details Not available
12-2900 110a411 Grinnell Street-DesignAction ItemsElevate house +/- 4” to FEMA elevation of 7’. Relocate front doors. New rear addition to extend existing sawtooth and exterior renovations- #411 Grinnell Street- Thomas E. Pope (H12-01-998)ApprovedPass Action details Video Video
12-2899 110b411 Grinnell Street-DemolitionAction ItemsDemolition of rear gazebo, shed and rear deck- #411 Grinnell Street- Thomas E. Pope (H12-01-998)-Second ReadingApprovedPass Action details Not available
12-2911 111730 Southard Street-Walk, Driveway, and FenceAction ItemsBrick entry walk and driveway. Concrete knee wall with wrought iron fence- #730 Southard Street- Craig Reynolds (H12-01-1003)ApprovedPass Action details Video Video
12-2912 112730 Southard Street-Chimney - WITHDRAWNAction ItemsRequest to rescind HARC approval H11-01-1757 to allow reconstruction of non functioning chimney to replicate original one- #730 Southard Street- Adele V. Stones (H12-01-1004)Withdrawn  Action details Not available
12-2913 113730 Southard Street-Porch JoistsAction ItemsAfter the fact approval to allow installation of three additional joists on second floor porch to meet current Florida Building Code floor loading requirement. Maintain historic porch joists with new joists milled to replace historic members- #730 Southard Street- Adele V. Stones (H12-01-1005)PostponedPass Action details Video Video
12-2914 114730 Southard Street-Porch FasciaAction ItemsAfter the fact approval to revise existing porch fascia detail to eliminate water retention and pooling at joinder of piers and porch joists in order to preserve integrity of porch joists and columns by extending fascia to a minimum protrusion of existing piers- #730 Southard Street- Adele V. Stones (H12-01-1006)DeniedPass Action details Video Video