Meeting Name: Contractors Examining Board Agenda status: Final
Meeting date/time: 12/6/2023 3:30 PM Minutes status: Final  
Meeting location: City Hall
Published agenda: Agenda Agenda Published minutes: Minutes Minutes  
Meeting video: eComment: Not available  
File #Ver.Agenda #NameTypeTitleActionResultAction DetailsVideo
Min 23-1299 11 MinutesSeptember 6, 2023Approved  Action details Not available
23-4080 22 Action Items(HEAR) Case: #2022-01542 Address: 10 Lowes Lane Contractor: Key West Trim Works (Luigi Vaccaro, III) Code Officer: Roman Stenko Count 1: Sec. 14-37 - Work performed beyond the scope of the issued permit. On 11/21/2022 Code Officer Roman Stenko, in response to a complaint regarding unpermitted work at the subject address 10 Lowes Lane. Officer Stenko along with Building Inspector Tarin Wright conducted an inspection where they observed and photographed work that was performed over the scope of permits that had been issued to the property (BLD22-3106 and BLD22-3108). The contractor of record is Key West Trim Works. A Stop Work Order was placed. Mr. Darek Lyzwinski is the property owner of record and stated that he worked for Key West Trim Works. They agreed to apply for an after the fact permit for Electrical Demo. Count 2: Sec. 14-40 Permit in historic districts; Failure to apply and obtain a certificate of appropriateness with the City of Key West HARC Department. Count 3: Sec. 18.117 Acts declared unlawful It shall be unlawful for any contractor, as defPostponed  Action details Not available
23-5148 13 Action Items(HEARING) Address: 1023 Grinnell St. Contractor: Wayne Garcia Builders Contr, Inc. (Wayne Garcia) Date of Violation(s) 9/12/2023 Code Violation: Count 1: Sec. 14-37 - Work permits; Failure to apply and obtain the appropriate permits. Address: 1023 Grinnell St. On 9/12/2023, Code Officer Keenan Mellendorf accompanied CBO Raj Ramsingh to his inspection of the subject property. When we arrived there was work (interior/exterior renovations) being performed on the house. The contractor present was Wayne Garcia. Raj Ramsingh informed him that some of the work that was being done at the time of our inspection was over the scope of what was currently approved. Mr. Ramsingh informed Mr. Garcia that he would need to submit some plans for approval and also obtain approval from HARC for some of the work. Mr. Garcia understood and said he would work on it. Count 2: Sec. 14-40 Permits in historic districts; Failure to apply and obtain a certificate of appropriateness with the City of Key West HARC Department. Sponsor: Mr. RamsinghApprovedPass Action details Not available
23-5149 14 Action Items(Hearing) Address: 718 Southard St. Contractor: Moore Builders, Inc. (Gary Elliott Moore, Jr.) Date of Violation(s) 9/12/2023 Code Violation: Count 1: Sec. 14-37 - Building permits; Failure to apply and obtain the appropriate permits. Address: 718 Southard St. On 9/12/2023, Code Officer Keenan Mellendorf accompanied CBO Raj Ramsingh to 718 Southard St. for an inspection after learning that the house had been demoed without permits or HARC approval. When we arrived we observed and photographed that the house had been almost completely demoed. Most, if not all historic elements of the house are gone. The roofing, flooring, electrical, and interior structural supports have all been removed. The contractor responsible is Moore Builders, Inc. Moore Builders pulled a permit for windows, wall petition, framing for interior doors, mill work, new columns in the rear structure, pool decking repair, pool storage area, and art stucco in April of 2022. A Stop Work Order was placed on the front door. Count 2: Sec. 14-40 - Permits in the historic districts: Failure toApproved  Action details Not available
23-5150 15 Action Items(Hearing) Address: 1015 Fleming St. Contractor: Tomkins Electric, LLC (Gary Luther Germanton) Date of Violation(s) 10/12/2023 Code Violation: Count 1: Sec. 14-37 - Building Permits; Failure to apply and obtain the appropriate permits. Address: 1015 Fleming St. On the morning of October 12th, 2023, during field inspections, Code Officer Ashton Gentry, observed and photographed workers and work materials in the parking lot adjacent to 1015 Fleming St. (Eden House). He approached the worker on-site who identified himself as Shawn Hollan of 5th Carpentry out of Sarasota, Fl. Shawn stated he was building stairways and decks on the property. Shawn stated he was not a licensed contractor and did not have permits for work. The property 1510 Fleming St. (Eden House) has an active permit for Pool resurfacing only. The work documented on site included extensive demolition of old decks and stairways and framing of new stairways and decks. The general manager of the property having daily plumbing issues being resolved by Patti the Plumber and the pool area also had a neApprovedPass Action details Not available