Share to Facebook Share to Twitter Bookmark and Share
Meeting Name: Code Compliance Hearing Agenda status: Final
Meeting date/time: 11/28/2018 1:30 PM Minutes status: Final  
Meeting location: City Hall
Published agenda: Agenda Agenda Published minutes: Minutes Minutes  
File #Ver.Agenda #NameTypeTitleActionResultAction DetailsVideo
18-2309 11 Code ViolationsCase # 18-280 Robert Janicki 1205 11th Street Sec. 14-37 Building permits; professional plans; display of permits; address; exceptions Sec. 14-262 Request for inspection FBC P2503.1 Inspections FBC 1612.4 Flood Hazard Construction Sec. 18-117 Acts declared unlawful Officer Bonnita Badgett Certified Service: 5-18-2018 Initial Hearing: 5-30-2018 Continued from 28 Nov 2018 for compliance Count 1: Building, electrical and plumbing work being done without the benefit of a permits. Count 2: Failure to request electrical inspection for work being done without the benefit of a permit. Count 3: Failure to request plumbing inspections for work being done without the benefit of a permit. Count 4:The new rear room in the main house, the tiki hut and shed shall comply to the ordinance for structures located in the flood hazard areas. Count 5: Cease using an unlicensed contractor.Continuance  Action details Video Video
18-3151 12 Code ViolationsCase # 18-996 Patricia Eables Joseph Crehan 313 Catherine Street 3 Sec. 74-206 Owner Responsibility Officer Bonnita Badgett Certified Mail: 10-30-2018 Initial Hearing: 11-25-2018 Continued from 28 Nov 2018 Count 1: Past due sewer, solid waste and storm water bills.Continuance  Action details Video Video
18-3154 13 Code ViolationsCase # 18-1736 Leo R. Rivas Jr Eugenia R. Rivas 3250 Duck Avenue Sec. 58-61 Determination and levy of charge Officer Bonnita Badgett Certified Mail: 12-1-2018 Initial Hearing: 11-28-2018 Continued from 28 Nov 2018 Count 1: Past due sewer, solid waste and storm water bill.Continuance  Action details Video Video
18-2114 14 Code ViolationsCase # 18-357 Bob Sunderman 922 Catherine Street Sec. 110-292 Failure to achieve a compliance agreement Officer Wherden Charles Certified Service: Initial Hearing: 4-25-2018 In compliance 21 Nov 2018; City request to vacate fines Count 1: For failure to come into compliance with the signed settlement agreement for violations Sec. 110-256 and 110-321. The payment of $500 and the planting of one coconut palm 8' tall has not been met.Continuance  Action details Video Video
18-3224 15 Code ViolationsCase # 18-1939 Kimberly Parker 3314 Northside Drive 13 Sec. 66-87 Business tax receipt required for all holding themselves out to be engaged in business Officer Wherden Charles Posted: 11-18-2018 Initial Hearing: 11-28-2018 In compliance 21 Nov 2018; request dismissal Count 1: The business tax receipt needs to be updated to reflect the second non-transient unit.Dismissed  Action details Video Video
18-3163 16 Code ViolationsCase # 18-613 Jana Ruzickova 1617 Bahama Drive Sec. 14-37 Building Permits Sec. 90-363 Certificate of Occupancy Sec. 14-261 Failure to obtain Sec. 14-262 Request for inspection Officer Sophia Doctoche Certified Mail: 10-23-2018 Initial Hearing: 11-28-2018 Continued from 28 Nov 2018 for compliance Count 1: Construction of a shed in the rear of the property without the benefit of required building permits. Count 2: Construction of a shed into a guest unit. Count 3: Failure to obtain an electrical permit for work performed. Count 4: Request for inspection for electrical work performed is required after permit is obtained.Continuance  Action details Video Video
18-2566 17 Code ViolationsCase # 18-849 Child Life Society Chaim A. Wolkenfeld 1000 17th Street Sec. 110-292 Failure to achieve a compliance agreement Officer Sophia Doctoche Posted: 7-5-2018 Initial Hearing: 7-25-2018 In compliance 02 Nov 2018; Request dismissal Count 1: Failure to achieve compliance regarding a settlement agreement with Karen Demaria of Urban Forestry.Dismissed  Action details Video Video
18-2773 18 Code ViolationsCase # 18-927 RCJB Properties Inc. 3402 Eagle Avenue Sec. 14-37 Building permits; professional plans; display of permits; address; exceptions Officer Sophia Doctoche Certified Service: 7-28-2018 Initial Hearing: 9-26-2018 Continued from 28 Nov 2018 for compliance Count 1: Failure to obtain permits for installation of a new door, windows and stucco on the house.Continuance  Action details Video Video
18-3052 19 Code ViolationsCase # 18-1009 Edward J Mccallum III Sharon S Mccallum 2617 Staples Avenue Sec. 14-37 Building permits; professional plans; display of permits; address; exceptions Sec. 14-262 Request for inspection Officer Sophia Doctoche Posted: 10-29-2018 Initial Hearing: 11-28-2018 Continued from 28 Nov 2018 Count 1: Replacement of a roof without the benefit of building permit. Count 2: Failure to obtain a final inspection.Continuance  Action details Video Video
18-2807 110 Code ViolationsCase # 18-1064 Heron House Court Marsh Enterprises of SW Florida Inc 412 Frances Street Sec. 14-37 Building permits; professional plans; display of permits; address; exceptions Officer Sophia Doctoche Certified Service: 8-21-2018 Initial Hearing: 9-26-18 Continued from 28 Nov 2018 for compliance Count 1: Failure to obtain a building permit for putting in a new fence.Continuance  Action details Video Video
18-3188 111 Code ViolationsCase # 18-1830 Elias Jefe 1108 Duval Street C Sec. 102-282 Outdoor display of goods Sec. 66-87 Business tax receipt required for all holding themselves out to be engaged in business Officer Sophia Doctoche Hand Served: 10-31-2018 Initial Hearing: 11-28-2018 In compliance 7 Nov 2018; Request dismissal Count 1: Merchandise and racks on the exterior door front are prohibited. Count 2: Required to apply for and obtain a business tax receipt for the business.Dismissed  Action details Video Video
2017-1427 112 Code ViolationsCase # 17-1198 Harold J Merritt II Marianne L Csigi 1301 Atlantic Drive Sec. 14-37 Building permits; professional plans; display of permits; address; exceptions - Dismissed Sec. 90-363 Certificate of Occupancy - required - Dismissed Sec. 58-61 Determination and levy of charge - Dismissed Sec. 14-262 Request for inspection - Dismissed FBC 1612.4 & ASCE 24-05 Floor hazard construction FBC 1612.5; ASCE 24-05 Sec 2.6 Flood venting required FBC 301.16 Flood hazard Scott Fraser Certified Service: 10-23-2017 Initial Hearing: 12-20-2017 Settlement Agreement Count 1: For failure to obtain building permits to convert the shed into habitable space. - Dismissed. Count 2: For failure to obtain a Certificate of Occupancy for the shed. - Dismissed. Count 3: For failure to obtain a solid waste account for shed. - Dismissed. Count 4: For failure to obtain an electrical inspection for installing electric in the storage area/habitable space below the house for the window air conditioners. - Dismissed. Count 5: For the construction of habitable space under the elevated home in a flood zone for usContinuance  Action details Video Video
18-2258 113 Code ViolationsCase # 17-716 Rockwell Property, Inc. - Property Owner Gregory G. Farrelly - Registered Agent 816 Fleming Street Sec. 14-37 Building permits; professional plans; display of permits; address; exceptions Officer Leonardo Hernandez Certified Service: 4-13-2018 - Registered Agent Certified Service: 4-16-2018 - Property Owner Initial Hearing: 5-30-2018 Continued from 26 Sept 2018 Count 1: Addition to the roof with black tar coating poured down that extends to the neighbor's property was erected without the required building permits.Continuance  Action details Video Video
18-2107 114 Code ViolationsCase # 18-69 Lam Fong Yin Tong Yat Hok 2108 Harris Avenue Sec. 14-37 Building permits; professional plans; display of permits; exceptions; address Sec. 14-261 Failure to obtain - Dismissed Sec. 14-262 Request for inspection Officer Leonardo Hernandez Posted: 4-10-2018 Initial Hearing: 4-25-2018 Administrative fees paid 05 Nov 2018; City request dismissal Count 1: For failure to obtain building permits for the interior work involving dry wall, ceiling and exterior porch roof coverage. Count 2: An electrical permit was obtained but the work performed was not done by that electrical contractor. - Dismissed. Count 3: For failure to obtain required electrical inspections.Dismissed  Action details Video Video
18-3048 115 Code ViolationsCase # 18-295 Renee R Spencer Fogarty Builders Christopher Fogarty 1405 12th Street Sec. 14-261 Failure to obtain - Dismissed Sec. 14-325 Permits required - Dismissed Sec. 14-37 Building permits; professional plans; display of permits; address; exceptions - Dismissed Sec. 14-327 Mechanical inspection - Dismissed FBC 1612.4 Flood hazard construction Sec. 14-262 Request for inspection - Dismissed Officer Leonardo Hernandez Posted: 10-29-2018 Initial Hearing: 10-31-2018 In compliance 30 Nov 2018; Pending fees Count 1: Failure to obtain an electrical permit. - Dismissed Count 2: Failure to obtain a mechanical permit. - Dismissed Count 3: Failure to obtain required building permits. - Dismissed Count 4: Failure to obtain mechanical inspections for permit #18-1721. - Dismissed Count 5: Failure to obtain required inspection for Florida Building Code FBC 16512.4. Count 6: Failure to obtain required final electrical inspection. - DismissedContinuance  Action details Video Video
18-2443 116 Code ViolationsCase # 18-536 Brugman Holdings LLC - Owner Thomas J Sireci, Jr - Registered Agent 10 Hilton Haven Drive C Sec. 14-37 Building permits; professional plans; display of permits; address; exceptions Officer Leonardo Hernandez Certified Service: 5-30-2018 - Owner Certified Service: 5-23-2018 - Registered Agent Initial Hearing: 6-27-2018 Continued from 28 Nov 2018 Count 1: Failure to obtain an after-the-fact building permit for interior framing of shed and dock behind shed.Continuance  Action details Video Video
18-3051 117 Code ViolationsCase # 18-1674 Tb36-Tb38 LLC Gregory K. Semmel Mario G. Mendoza III, P.A. - Registered Agent 1075 Duval Street Unit R15-R16 Sec. 14-37 Building permits; professional plans; display of permits; address; exceptions - In compliance 2 Nov 2018; Request dismissal FBC P2503.1 Inspection Required Officer Leonardo Hernandez Certified Mail: 11-01-2018 - Tb36-Tb38 LLC Certified Mail: 10-22-2018 - Mario G. Mandoza III Initial Hearing: 11-28-2018 In compliance 28 Nov 2018; Request dismissal Count 1: Interior renovations, demolition and drywall work being done without the benefit of building permits. Count 2: Plumbing inspection required for the after-the-fact plumbing permit obtained 10.16.2018.Continuance  Action details Video Video
2017-1065 118 Code ViolationsCase # 16-773 Brittany D Delgado Mark R Delgado Estate 2807 Seidenberg Avenue Sec. 90-363 Certificate of occupancy - Required Sec. 58-61 Determination and levy of charge Sec. 66-87 Business tax receipt required for all holding themselves out to be engaged in business Officer Beau Langford Certified Service: Posted: 8-10-2017 Posted: 7-10-2018 Initial Hearing: 8-30-2017 Continued from 28 Nov 2018 for compliance Count 1: Failure to obtain a Certificate of Occupancy for residential unit in the rear of the property. Count 2: Failure to have Utilities associated with the residential unit in the rear of the property. Count 3: Failure to have a non-transient business tax receipt for the residential unit in the rear of the property.Continuance  Action details Video Video
2017-1318 119 Code ViolationsCase # 16-1570 Robert Reilly Nicola Roques 1535 5th Street Sec. 14-37 Building permits; professional plans; display of permits; address; exceptions FBC 1612.4 Flood Hazard Construction & ASCE 24-05 Unprotected Enclosed Below Design Flood Elevation Sec. 122-238 Dimensional requirements. Paragraph 6, Section a. Single-family Officer Beau Langford Certified Service: 10-16-2017 Initial Hearing: 11-15-2017 In compliance 10 Dec 2018; Request dismissal Count 1: Construction of a new one room structure and roof structural changes to the original house have been made without the benefit of required permits. Count 2: Did install, or installing or allowed to be installed, an inhabitable structure within a FEMA designated AE-8 flood zone, below the minimum required elevation deemed necessary for flood damage prevention. Count 3: One room structure is currently being built within the rear setback of the property and possibly on top of a 10' utility easement.Continuance  Action details Video Video
18-1791 120 Code ViolationsCase # 18-06 Brian Sharples - Director - Counts 3 through 20 Corporation Service Company - Registered Agent D/B/A CSC - Lawyers Inc. - Counts 3 through 20 Michael J McMahon - Counts 1 through 20 107 Front Street Unit 217 Sec. 18-601 License required - Irreparable Sec. 122-1371 Transient living accommodations in residential dwellings; regulations Sec. 122-1371 Transient living accommodations in residential dwellings; regulations (d) (9) Officer Beau Langford Certified Service: 1-12-2018 - Brian Sharples Certified Service: 1-17-2018 - Corporate Service Company Certified Service: Initial Hearing: 2-28-2018 Continued from 28 Nov 2018 Count 1: During a routine inspection, found a black Cadillac parked in the subjects parking space. Made contact with Frances and Valerie Sirotzki inside the unit. Mrs. Sirotzki forwarded the rental agreement along with all correspondence between the couple, HomeAway and Michael J McMahon. Rental agreement was for 18 nights, dates of 19 Dec 2017 through 6 Jan 2018 for a total of $21,787,66. Count 2: The subject property has not had the requContinuance  Action details Video Video
18-2104 121 Code ViolationsCase # 17-1146 Jordan James & Sara Key 1309 Newton Street Sec. 14-37 Building permits; professional plans; display of permits; address; exceptions - In compliance 9 Nov 2018; Request dismissal Sec. 14-40 Permits in historic districts - In compliance 9 Nov 2018; Request dismissal Sec. 14-262 Request for inspection Officer Jorge Lopez Certified Service: 3-26-2018 Initial Hearing: 4-25-2018 Continued from 28 Nov 2018 for compliance Count 1: For failure to obtain a mechanical permit to install the A/C condenser on the roof. Count 2: For failure to obtain HARC approval for installation of the A/C condenser on the roof. Count 3: For failure to obtain an inspection for the A/C condenser.Continuance  Action details Video Video
18-2433 122 Code ViolationsCase # 17-1203 Browning Family Irrevocable Trust Michael Leo Browning 1300 White Street Sec. 78-126 Required Sec. 78-91 Required Officer Jorge Lopez Posted: 7-2-2018 Initial Hearing: 6-27-2018 Continued from 28 Nov 2018 Count 1: Subject business owner has not renewed their vehicle for hire license. Count 2: The subject individual has not received their documented permit which is required to operate a passenger vehicle for hire within the city limits.Continuance  Action details Video Video
2017-1429 123 Code ViolationsCase # 17-1213 Erwin Mayer & Didier R Moritz - property owner 1300 15th Court Lot 77 Sec. 90-363 Certificate of Occupancy - required Sec. 58-61 Determination and levy of charge Sec. 14-37 Building permits; professional plans; display of permits; address; exceptions Officer Jorge Lopez Certified Service: 11-16-2017 Initial Hearing: 12-20-2017 Continuance granted to 30 Jan 2019 for compliance Count 1: For failure to obtain a certificate of occupancy for the addition that was built. Count 2: For failure to pay impact fees related to utilities. Count 3: For failure to obtain building permits for the addition to the trailer and for the installed plumbing.Continuance  Action details Video Video
18-2557 124 Code ViolationsCase # 17-1579 Home Depot U.S.A. Inc. Corporation Service Company - Registered Agent 2811 North Roosevelt Boulevard Sec. 26-192 Unreasonably excessive noise prohibited Officer Jorge Lopez Certified Service: 6-15-2018 Initial Hearing: 7-25-2018 Continued from 28 Nov 2018 Count 1: Noise complaint was investigated and the noise emanating from the subject property on 8 Jan 2018 was 83.9 Decibels which exceeds the noise limitation of 77 Decibels. As of this date, the subject property has not scheduled a sound reading to check that the noise level is within the limits set forth by the ordinance.Continuance  Action details Video Video
18-2958 125 Code ViolationsCase # 18-46 Jana Kopkova Kukal Vaclav 3304 Duck Avenue Sec. 14-37 Building permits; professional plans; display of permits; address; exceptions Officer Jorge Lopez Certified Service: 09-25-2018 Initial Hearing: 10-31-2018 Continued from 28 Nov 2018 Count 1: Failure to obtain required permits for the enclosed driveway and new roof.Continuance  Action details Video Video
18-2276 126 Code ViolationsCase # 18-392 Silver KW, Inc. Alon Croitoru - Registered Agent 137 Duval Street 141 Sec. 14-37 Building permits; professional plans; display of permits; address; exceptions Sec. 14-40 Permits in historic districts Sec. 114-103 Prohibited signs Sec. 2-939 Licenses Officer Jorge Lopez Certified Service: 6-11-2018 Initial Hearing: 5-30-2018 Continued from 28 Nov 2018 for compliance Count 1: New installation of rolling steel doors on the exterior of the building without the benefit of a permit. Count 2: The rolling steel doors and the hanging sign over the sidewalk were installed without the benefit of a certificate of appropriateness. Count 3: Multiple prohibited signs on the exterior of the building. Count 4: The sign hanging over the sidewalk does not have a revocable license.Continuance  Action details Video Video
18-2764 127 Code ViolationsCase # 18-595 Curtis A Skomp 410 Caroline Street Sec. 14-40 Permits in historic districts Officer Jorge Lopez Certified Service: 8-6-2018 Initial Hearing: 9-26-2018 Continued from 28 Nov 2018 Count 1: Failure to obtain required HARC permit for approval of signage.Continuance  Action details Video Video
18-2562 128 Code ViolationsCase # 18-673 John Cameron Lara Schmidt 620 Thomas Street 178 Sec. 14-325 Permit required - Dismissed Sec. 14-37 Building permits; professional plans; display of permits; address; exceptions - Dismissed Sec. 14-40 Permits in historic districts - Dismissed Sec. 14-262 Request for inspection Officer Jorge Lopez Certified Service: 6-28-2018 Initial Hearing: 7-25-2018 Continued from 29 Nov 2018 for compliance Count 1: Installation of the HVAC system without required permit. - Dismissed Count 2: The HVAC system was installed without required mechanical permit. - Dismissed Count 3: HVAC system was installed without certificate of appropriateness. - Dismissed Count 4: HVAC installed without required permits and inspections.Continuance  Action details Video Video
18-2455 129 Code ViolationsCase # 18-675 Victor & Cynthia Mills 1202 White Street Sec. 14-37 Building permits; professional plans; display of permits; address; exceptions Sec. 14-325 Permit required - Dismissed Sec. 14-262 Request for inspection - Dismissed Officer Jorge Lopez Certified Service: 6-6-2018 Initial Hearing: 6-27-2018 In compliance 27 Nov 2018; Request dismissal Count 1: Failure to obtain all required permits for drywall work and ceiling work. Count 2: Failure to obtain mechanical permits for the HVAC system installation. - Dismissed Count 3: Failure to obtain all required inspections. - DismissedDismissed  Action details Video Video
18-3050 130 Code ViolationsCase # 18-1163 D.L. Porter Construction, Inc. C. White Marshall - Registered Agent 1314 Simonton Street Sec. 14-37 Building permits; professional plans; display of permits; address; exceptions Sec. 14-40 Permits in Historic Districts Officer Jorge Lopez Certified Mail: 10-16-2018 - G. White Marshall Initial Hearing: 11-28-2018 In compliance 09 Nov 2018; Request dismissal Count 1: Stucco work being done without the benefit of a building permit. Count 2: Stucco work being done without a certificate of appropriateness from HARC.Dismissed  Action details Video Video
18-2804 131 Code ViolationsCase # 18-1177 Victor & Cynthia Mills 1204 White Street Sec. 14-37 Building permits; professional plans; display of permits; address; exceptions Officer Jorge Lopez Certified Service: Initial Hearing: 9-26-2018 In compliance 27 Nov 2018; Request dismissal Count 1: Failure to obtain building permits for drywall work.Dismissed  Action details Video Video
18-3155 132 Code ViolationsCase # 18-1178 Old Town Trolley Tours of Washington, Inc. Edwin Swift III - Registered Agent 201 Front Street Suite 224 Sec. 14-37 Building permits; professional plans; display of permits; address; exceptions Sec. 14-40 Permits in Historic districts Officer Jorge Lopez Certified Mail: 10-23-2018 Initial Hearing: 11-28-2018 Continued from 28 Nov 2018 Count 1: Directory sign was replaced without benefit of building permit. Count 2: Directory sign replaced without the benefit of a certificate of appropriateness.Continuance  Action details Video Video
18-3077 133 Code ViolationsCase # 18-1667 Leslie Yates 531 Fleming Street Sec. 14-37 Building permits; professional plans; display of permits; address; exceptions - In compliance 28 Sept 2018; Request dismissal Sec. 18-150 Certificate of competency required Sec. 66-87 Business tax receipt required for all holding out to be engaged in business Officer Jorge Lopez Hand Served: 10-11-2018 Initial Hearing: 10-31-2018 New Case Count 1: Roof work being done with a permit that the contractor's insurance had expired. A stop work order was posted. Count 2: Contractor who received payment for doing the roofing work does not have a certificate of competency. Count 3: The contractor who performed the roof work does not have a City of Key West business tax receipt.Violation Fine  Action details Video Video
18-3190 134 Code ViolationsCase # 17-1283 Ted J McByrnett Estate Joseph Krygier 1007 Thomas Street Motion For Reconsideration of Mitigation Of FinesDismissed  Action details Not available